Author: Oliver Hair ASyI,
Threat Analyst
Read Time: 3 minutes
On 15 October 2023, France was put on its highest level of terrorism alert following an Islamist-inspired Bladed Weapons attack at a French school on 13 October 2023. According to French police, the perpetrator was known to the security services for his involvement with Islamist extremism and was under electronic and physical surveillance by France’s domestic intelligence agency at the time of the attack.[1] On 17 October, France’s anti-terrorism prosecutor Jean-Francois Ricard revealed that the individual had pledged allegiance to Islamic State prior to the attack.[2] There was one fatality and three others were injured.[3]
Event Assessment
- It is almost certain that Islamist terrorism remains the dominant terrorist threat in Western Europe and the UK at this time. Islamist terrorists have previously demonstrated the intent and capability to conduct attacks in France, including:
- 2020 – Paris – An Islamist terrorist conducted a Bladed Weapons attack against a teacher at a school near Paris. The teacher, who was killed in the attack, was reportedly targeted for showing cartoons of the Prophet Muhammad in the classroom.[4]
- 2016 – Nice – Islamic State claimed responsibility for a Vehicle as a Weapon attack against crowds on Bastille Day in Nice. The perpetrator drove through crowds for approximately two kilometres before being shot by police. There were 86 fatalities.[5]
- 2015 – Paris – Islamist terrorists conducted a complex high-sophistication attack across Paris. The attack involved Firearms and Person-Borne Improvised Explosive Devices. There were 130 fatalities and hundreds more were wounded.[6]
- 2015 – Paris – Two Islamist terrorists conducted a Firearms attack against the offices of Charlie Hebdo, a satirical French newspaper in Paris.[7] There were 12 fatalities, and 11 others were injured.[8]
- It is highly likely that any terrorist attack conducted by an Islamist terrorist in Western Europe or the UK would be conducted by a small cell or a lone individual using a low sophistication methodology. E.g., Bladed or Blunt Force Weapons, Vehicle as a Weapon, or Fire as a Weapon.
- There is a realistic possibility that Islamist terrorists in the UK could have the capability to conduct a high-sophistication attack at this time. E.g., Improvised Explosive Device. The complicated nature of plotting a high-sophistication terrorist attack makes it highly likely that there will be greater opportunity for UK police and security services to disrupt potential attacks.
- There is a realistic possibility that the Israel-Hamas conflict could act as a driver of terrorism threat in the UK and Europe in the long term as community tensions increase during the conflict and individuals become susceptible to radicalisation towards violence.
- On 17 October 2023, Director General of MI5 Ken McCallum warned that events in the Middle East could radicalise people towards violence in the UK. The Director General stated that “it has always been the case that would-be-terrorists in the UK draw inspiration through their distorted understanding of what is happening in other countries”.[9]
- In France, the French Prime Minister Élisabeth Borne claimed “the attack against Israel could have been a trigger element” for the recent terrorism-related incident at a school in in France.[10]
- In the UK, the Community Security Trust (CST), a charity which protects British Jews from antisemitism and related threats, issued a statement that its records showed that antisemitic incidents in the UK have “increased by 581%” since 7 October 2023.[11] The CST recorded 15 incidents of assaults, 14 incidents of damage to Jewish property and 224 related to abusive behaviour since the beginning of the conflict.[12]
- It is almost certain that the Israel-Hamas conflict would lead to an increase in the number of Non-Violent Direct Action (NVDA) protests conducted across the UK. Media reporting suggests that on 14 October 2023, “tens of thousands” of individuals protested in Manchester, Liverpool, Edinburgh, Glasgow, Aberdeen and London. 15 individuals were reportedly arrested at a protest in London.[13] On 13 October 2023, Palestine Action Group (PAG) claimed responsibility for covering the BBC’s London headquarters with red paint.[14] There is a realistic possibility that individuals conducting NVDA protests relating to the Israel-Hamas conflict could mature to violence in the medium term.
Intelligence Cut-Off Date: 18 October 2023
PHIA Scale
The “Probability Yardstick” (below) is a standardised instrument used to provide professional intelligence assessments. Judgements made using the yardstick are relative and reflect the analyst’s confidence in their findings and assessments.
-
- Almost Certain: An event is assessed to have a greater than 90% chance of occurring.
- Highly Likely: An event is assessed to have a 76% to 90% chance of occurring.
- Likely: An event is assessed to have a 55% to 75% chance of occurring.
- Realistic Possibility: An event is assessed to have a 40% to 54% chance of occurring.
- Unlikely: An event is assessed to have a 25% to 39% chance of occurring.
- Highly Unlikely: An event is assessed to have an 10% to 24% chance of occurring.
- Remote Chance: An event is assessed to have a less than 10% chance of occurring.
Time Spans
-
- Short Term: 0 – 6 Months.
- In the next 12 months.
- Medium Term: 12 months – 5 Years.
- Long Term: 5+ Years.
End Notes
[1] France deploying 7,000 soldiers following deadly school stabbing as Louvre evacuated after threat | World News | Sky News; France raises security level after school knife attack – BBC News
[2] Suspect in killing of French teacher pledged allegiance to Islamic State-prosecutor | Reuters
[3] France raises security level after school knife attack – BBC News
[4] France teacher attack: Students ‘paid €300’ to identify Samuel Paty – BBC News
[5] Nice: Eight guilty over the deadly Bastille Day lorry attack – BBC News
[6] Paris attacks: What happened on the night – BBC News
[7] Charlie Hebdo attack: Three days of terror – BBC News
[8] Paris Attacks: How Europe’s Terrorists Get Illegal Guns (time.com)
[9] MI5 fears Israel-Gaza war could fuel radicalisation – BBC News
[10] Macron calls for ‘ruthless’ approach to extremism in wake of Arras attack | France | The Guardian
[11] UK antisemitic incidents up by 581% since outbreak of Israel-Gaza war, Jewish security group say | ITV News
[12] Antisemitic incidents ‘quadruple in UK’ since Hamas attack in Israel – BBC News
[13] Tens of thousands of protesters across UK call for a free Palestine | London | The Guardian
[14] Pro-Palestinian group claims responsibility for covering BBC’s London headquarters in red paint | UK News | Sky News
Author: Oliver Hair ASyI,
Threat Analyst